This was originally posted on February 8, 2009. I re-post it here as part of my coverage of this year's Hugo Awards.
The Shadow Rising
Robert Jordan concluded The Dragon Reborn with Rand Al’Thor holding the Stone of Tear and the crystalline sword Callandor,
the sword that is not a sword. Taking the sword and holding the stone
were the two primary signs to the world that Rand was, in fact, the
Dragon Reborn. The surprise was the desert dwelling warrior Aiel
helped Rand take Tear, believing he may be their Car’a’carn, one spoken of in their prophecies the same way the Dragon Reborn is spoken of, except that the Aiel actively search for their Car’a’carn and the Dragon Reborn is dreaded.
The Shadow Rising
deals with the fallout of Rand taking Tear. The novel opens with
stagnation, with Rand refusing to act (much to Moiraine’s frustration),
but after a couple hundred pages (really) Robert Jordan begins to move
the action. Perrin returns to the Two Rivers to protect his home and
his people. Rand travels with the Aiel to Rhuidian, though he may not
know exactly why. Mat, too. Moiraine and Egwene follow, Egwene to
study with the Aiel Wise Women to learn more of being a Dreamwalker.
can grant the argument some readers may make about the opening
stagnation, but even there Jordan lays out some fascinating stuff.
Weird things occur to Rand, Mat, and Perrin. They are each randomly
attacked – Rand by his reflection, Perrin by his axe, and Mat by playing
cards. Jordan pulls it off, though when written down in a single
sentence it may not sound very thrilling or dangerous, but this is evil
tainted and well done. Lanfear makes another appearance, telling Rand
that he will need to learn to control saidin or the other Forsaken may
destroy him…and that Rand needs a teacher, a male Forsaken to teach him.
Rand and Mat each step through a ter’angreal leading to the world of
the aelfinn, weird creatures talking in riddles.
Mat is told that
his fate is “to marry the Daughter of the Nine Moons”, “to die and live
again, and live once more a part of what was”, “to give up half the
light of the world to save the world”. Just in case anyone thought that
Mat might NOT be important…yeah, Mat is important.
See, this is part of what I like best about The Shadow Rising.
Robert Jordan doles out mystery and history throughout the novel and
more than his skill at storytelling, the weaving of the history and
foreshadowing draws me in. If we’ve been paying attention we know
already that the Court of the Nine Moons is Seanchan, though it is easy
to overlook because we don’t know why those mentions in the previous two
books might be important. This is why.
The main reason I am so
fond of this book, though, is Rhuidian. When Rand walks through the
ter’angreal rings at Rhuidian he gets to live scenes from his ancestry,
scenes of the history of the Aiel, who they are and who they were. What
they were. Through these sequences we get our second glimpse of the
Age of Legends – before, during, and after the Breaking of the World.
For me, Rhuidian is worth the price of admission. But, there is more,
some of which I thought was in the next book – the uprising in the White
Tower, Nynaeve besting Moghedien, Rand fighting Asmodean, Rand
discovering how to Travel, Slayer, Lord Perrin, more.
The Shadow Rising
is ultimately an uneven book. There are long, long passages with
little of note occurring and we may well feel that we’re just waiting
for the next major set piece to come up, but at the same time Robert
Jordan’s world is an old friend and though this is the fourth book in
the series Jordan delivers several major events that continue to build
towards something potentially very big. Jordan has not yet hit the
wall, and while The Shadow Rising is a bit slower than I remembered, there was also more goodness than I remembered.
Nynaeve Braid Tug Count
The Eye of the World: 0
The Great Hunt: 0
The Dragon Reborn: 8
The Shadow Rising: 1
Okay, giving The Shadow Rising
a braid-tug count of 1 is an arguable position but I feel confident
about it. There are several moments throughout the novel where Nynaeve
grabs her braid or holds her braid, but only the one tug that I noticed.
Nynaeve “gripped the end in her fist” on page 85 and “gripped her
braid hard” on page 90. The braids don’t make another appearance (that I
noticed) until page 586 where Elayne observes that Nynaeve “seemed to
have given up trying to pull at those braids when she was angry.” It is
only on page 596 that Nynaeve tugs her braid for the first time in the
novel. It is unclear if there are multiple tugs in this passage or just
one, so I’m going with a count of 1 for The Shadow Rising. So far the braid tugging doesn’t seem overwhelming, with only 9 total tugs over the 2000+ pages of text.